Perception.
September 13, 2009
what is perception to all of you?
this was brought up in class last week. while everyone was busy shouting out their answers, the first thing that came into my mind was “how i see things/others? and what i think of them?” of course this is merely a layman’s term of the word itself. in definition, perception is the process by which we make sense of the world around us.
take a look at this video. i am certain that most of you would have seen it once, or even twice. (actually i’m sure i wont be the only one writing about this issue but i’m most willing to give you my two cents worth on the matter)
to cut the story short, Miss Ris Low, current winner of Miss Singapore World has been criticized harshly on her inability to speak well in English. her few mins of ‘fame’ on youtube has earned her a entry in Wikipedia, of which one shouldnt be very proud about actually.
“There has been scandals around Singapore forums and websites that Ris has won the crown despicably and that she is undeserving of the title. There have been calls to strip Ris’s title as Miss Singapore World 2009 as well.”
WHAT??? how can her poor speech itself lead to accusations whereby she won the crown despicably? hundreds of netizens have also commented about her ‘ah-lian‘ image and this leads to ‘slutty and cheap’. what kind of a baseless accusation is that? right in this example alone exemplifies how when situations are viewed without understanding, the mind will try to reach for something that it already recognizes, in order to process what it is viewing. in this case, the common theory that ah-lians are uneducated, hence lacking dignity.
moreover, the video above was created by an obviously insensitive Singaporean who included uncalled-for subtitles to mock her pronunciation. the extent of this hate video of her is morally unjustifiable and it only seeks attention from other critics. she’s only 19, and definitely does not deserve the intensity of the insults thrown at her. i find it commendable that she is putting in effort in improving her speech, and we should as fellow Singaporeans, show her our utmost support.
maybe learning about perception as an idea on the whole has taught me to see things at a bigger angle. it is definitely unfair to assume she is undeserving of the title just looking at a few minutes of her interview. sadly, it is true to say that our communication and behaviour are based on our perception itself rather than on reality. and this can be very deceptive indeed.
(taken from Lifestyle 130909)
i am secretly glad that the Head of the Speak Good English Movement has come to her defence. it gives others a mature view on the entire matter itself, as well as a reminder to ourselves. i quote Mr Goh, “how many people are you laughing at if you laugh at Miss Low?”
i can understand perfectly how our personal prejudices play a significant role in the way we perceive things. but nevertheless, we shouldnt view things on the surface and then perceive the situation narrowly. personally i admit that her speech is indeed poor but it gives us no right to label her as a disgrace to our country or someone who slept her way to win the title. netizens should think twice before commenting blatantly on her character as a whole. that said, we must also be aware that there will not be a time where everybody sees eye to eye when perception comes into place.
a highly educated scholar may perceive Ms Low as uneducated, withholding the mindset she will lead Singapore to further disgrace with her inadequate speech. similarly, someone who may not be well-versed in English might not understand the big uproar the video has ignited.
hopefully after all the heated exchange on different views and perception, we will learn to place facts first before merely coming to conclusions that might appear childish based on one’s belief alone.
food for thought : what is your idea of perception and how does it affect the decisions you make in life?
S



September 13, 2009 at 10:48 am
I feel that Miss Singapore should not only be attractive, charismatic, sensitive, knowledgeable and also be able to carry herself well. Ris Low is of title-winning-calibre as long as she doesn’t have to speak a word. There was only one word to describe that mere 4 minute interview of her, painful. She sounded shallow and has no clue what the interviewer was asking.
Many people around the world still have little knowledge of us, this little red dot. And Miss Ris Low might be the first Singaporean they come across. This doesn’t impress, or worse, this might even leave them with a negative impression.
I am not faulting Miss Ris Low for having a poor command of English but for her to represent Singapore, I’m definitely on the flip side.
September 13, 2009 at 11:00 am
yoo hoo! i guess my idea of perception is somewhat similar to yours. we have to be sensitive when we put perception into place. when i’m making big decisions in life, i usually ask for the opinions of others because at times i’m afraid i will be let down by my own misjudgment.
September 13, 2009 at 11:11 am
((: the only thing i can say about this woman, is that she is a disgrace to Singapore & an embarrassment to the society. The judges must have been blind to have let her win.
I rather someone not as pretty but who speaks really well, represent Singapore than Ris Low. At least Singaporeans will come across as not so goodlooking but maybe witty or intellectual, instead of pretty but dumb.
However, with all that said, it’s probably just my perception. Who knows, she could be actually really smart. When i make a huge decision in my life, i usually just ask myself a few questions :
1. will i be happy?
2. is this right? would my conscience approve of it?
3. will my friends support my choice?
& thats kinda all that matters.
September 13, 2009 at 12:04 pm
Miss Singapore is meant as a representation of Singapore. Given that, the winner ought to portray an accurate perspective on our culture and the way we carry ourselves. Yes, the competition is also about the looks, but that’s more of a secondary issue.
In my personal opinion, the winner does display the behaviour and normalities of the average Singaporean accurately, however it was a little over the top. It is important for us to shine our nation in a positive light, but the winner didn’t quite achieve that effect. Her answers were unsophisticated and she came across rather superficial, and if non-Singaporeans were to see her responses they would frown rather than stand impressed. The fact alone that there are Singaporeans complaining and throwing snide comments already speaks for itself that she failed to provide a decent presentation of the nation.
September 13, 2009 at 2:43 pm
As someone who has no idea what is going on in Singapore at the moment, just from watching the video, I’ve come up with a few opinions of my own.
Firstly, I’m sure she’s a really nice person with a good personality and so on and she doesn’t deserve to be ridiculed on youtube like that, just because her english is not up the the standard that people expect of someone who is about to represent Singapore.
Secondly, I think the judges are to blame. She did not force them to pick her, the choice was up to them so to me , I think it’s unfair to pick on her.
However, everyone has a point about her being the wrong choice as someone to be the face of our little country. Just by talking, she would actually reinforce the idea of asians being unable to speak english properly. Many singaporeans overseas have been given the comment “hey … your english is pretty good , I can actually understand you”. Which is quite an insult.
So I guess, having Ris Low would not be a very wise idea. But all these ideas are shaped by how everyone from different cultures and races are brought up to view each other .
September 13, 2009 at 4:50 pm
HI!
Yea i guess it’s pretty unfair that everyone is just throwing her personal insults and ridiculing her because of how she pronounces her words and the way she speaks in the video. But I guess she is competing for the title of Miss Singapore World, and don’t you expect the winners of such beauty pageants should have a reasonable standard of English? It might be a beauty contest and beauty is one of the top priorities. She is pretty no doubt however, but is she really someone that is best to represent Singapore as Miss Singapore World?
She is going to travel overseas and represent us as a country and honestly, isn’t it a little embarrassing? At least she’s making the effort to improve, and kudos to that. But still.. You get what i mean. Is there really no other contestant with the beauty and can express herself better in english? (Wm gives her credit for being brave enough to embarrass herself on national television)
Oh well!! We love you stef
September 13, 2009 at 5:07 pm
No comments on the whole Ris Low topic but i’ll touch a little on how perception can be influenced..
Perception of a situation differs from each individual. How the person interprets it depends on factors such as experience and assumptions. The person will think he/she is right, although in actual fact it is a biased point of view.
10 brains are better than 1. Try listening with an open mind when others share their perceptions with you and be amazed by how they can help you see things in different ways that you wouldn’t have thought of.
At the end of it, you will realise that your perception of a situation might change for the better as you now see it from different angles.
Cheers ^^
September 13, 2009 at 5:25 pm
well, i do feel that people nowadays are superficial and shallow in a certain extent. People of our society nowadays,critique every single thing. Would we want to be critisized that way if we were in those the shoes of people that tried their best but instead getting laughed and mocked at? I do feel that perceptions do affects good communication and most importantly, a society that is united and understanding. Well done Stefanie! I agree to whatever you said in your post.keep it up
September 13, 2009 at 5:27 pm
We may be too quick to judge and claim that she does not deserve this title without looking at her personality. However, would you present a gift tt’s unsightly to someone you’re meeting for the first time? Same goes for this, it would leave a bad impression on th rest o th world if she’s being sent abroad to represent our country in th pageant. And yes, we may not speak perfect English, but we definitely don’t stumble in every sentence we speak!
September 13, 2009 at 6:40 pm
and furthermore, why are people blaming her for her lack of qualities when she didnt vote herself?well, she doesnt play any fault in this and people perceive her as stealing the crown? this is outrageous.
September 13, 2009 at 6:42 pm
i mean the fact that she won it. aint her fault at all.people voted for her.
September 13, 2009 at 10:01 pm
very insightful points. i am impressed by your depth of thought and intelligence in general. also, i like owls.
September 13, 2009 at 10:01 pm
i meant to say, you seem as wise as an owl
September 14, 2009 at 1:25 am
to add on to your point, perception is the process people use to make sense out of the environment by selecting, organizing and interpreting information.
therefore, there will be perceptual biases and errors when forming your own judgement.
what is important is that you are aware of your own perceptual biases and learn from other people’s view which are different from yours and not be hasty to make decisions and behave in a manner that you might regret later on.
cheers!
September 14, 2009 at 7:15 am
I feel that we shouldn’t confuse perception with actual facts, especially in the case with people. After all, what we perceive may only be extremely superficial and on the surface, which isn’t going to be an accurate portrayal of one’s character.
I personally try to remain as objective as possible when it comes to passing judgement on another’s character and the critique of flaws. After all, each individual has different viewpoints and perspectives and we should not try to enforce what we ourselves believe upon others.
September 14, 2009 at 2:01 pm
well believe it or not, this Miss Low was my school mate last time.
i wouldnt want to comment here about how i feel about she winning the title crown because it would be biased. either i’m a fan or i’m not.
but i do agree with you that we should give her a chance as she’s only a mere 19 year old teenager, whose life has been magnified under the media’s lens since she won the title.
the media is so intergrated into our daily lives now that it’s important we dont misuse this tool. but sadly, the world we live in, have been misusing the tool for such long time. for example, the person who made that video of Ris Low. he misused his knowledge on video-editing to produce this video out, add in subtitles that are ridiculous.
but well, this is his perception of Ris Low and as an individual, we dont really have the right to say about his actions too.
September 14, 2009 at 3:52 pm
Oh perception, the very thing which makes way for debates, forums and the like. Formed by the way we were taught to think, perception is a keyhole which allows us to get a grip on events happening around us, and eventually we draw up action plans to cope with new situations coming our way (also based on our perceptions of how certain actions may be of aid to our constitutions).
Perception helps us improve only if we are receptive to different views from others. Singapore does not have a cabinet of ministers for nothing, as does most of the rest of the world. And what about the time when Galileo was mocked by majority of the world for his perception that the sun is at the center of the solar system?
In consensus, indeed perception is a gateway to improvement and advancement, as long as we have the courage, the means and the medium to voice them out. Perception, breeds ideas to a better future. Have a good day dear Stefanie.
September 15, 2009 at 8:19 am
I don’t think that people should condemn Ris and make accusations such as her sleeping her way to the top when they have no concrete proof to justify these words.
However I feel that as Miss Singapore World 2009, she is a representation of Singapore and thus should be more careful of how she presents herself and the way she speaks. By not doing so she is subjecting not only herself to scrutiny but the whole of Singapore to criticism.
When someone from another country who is not aware of Singapore’s reputation looks at Ris, they might assume that this is a representation of majority of Singaporeans. After all in such a competition, one would expect each country to send their best, wouldn’t they?
September 15, 2009 at 12:54 pm
She ain’t fit for the title man… but I am glad that she won because the singapore’s speak good in english (watever the name) campaign clearly wasn’t doing enough to get locals to speak proper english. So I hope people would perceive her a as just an example of how usually locals talk and recognize that they need to improve their english.
Namka
http://lifestoolong.wordpress.com
September 15, 2009 at 4:36 pm
Well if she signed up for the competition she must have been well aware of the risks. Everyone has their detractors, even big-name celebrities and popular politicians. What say a so-called national representative of Singapore?
The blame does not lie with Ris per se. She did her best, and she won. If anything, the judges should take the blame for choosing her as the winner. The winner should above all, be able to represent Singapore. A decent command of the English language would definitely be one of the basic requirements for the winner, don’t you think? Isn’t she supposed to be the cream of the crop, not just the prettiest but not lacking intellectually?
Then again, the judges might have had their hands tied, what if all of the contestants are unable to converse decently? We have a problem in the education system on our hands then.
September 15, 2009 at 5:08 pm
Most of our perceptions tend to be coloured by the perceptions of other people. The initial perception is usually the most accurate representation of your own thoughts. Knowing this, why not try being aware of your own initial perceptions, remember it, compare it with the perceptions of other people, and gauge the amount of bias that skews your actual perception.
All that harping about a gracious society isn’t going to help anything if we cannot even understand how people fit differently in society. With understanding, there might be less misunderstanding and more empathy to go around.
November 8, 2009 at 4:13 pm
Hi everyone thanks for all your comments. I have read each and everyone of them and they were very useful to me! Appreciate them, really. Anws I just have to say my perception of Ris Low has changed after her “Credit Card Fraud” case. I feel that she does not deserve the title because to represent Singapore, it is most important that you do not have a black record. This will leave foreigners a very bad impression. However, my stand stays the same when I say that she should not be judged on a few mistakes. Everyone should be given a second chance afterall. Whats more, she claimed to have learnt from her mistakes and she definitely gets the benefit of the doubt from me!
THANK YOU ALL